Voters in the Vincent ward will head to the polls following the resignation of newly elected councillor Dave McKenzie in October.The by-election will determine a new representative on the district council, with three candidates standing for this role.As part of our election coverage, we have put four questions to each candidate, covering key issues facing the ward and the wider district.All candidates were given the same questions, a 200-word word limit for each response, and the same deadline.Their answers will be published over the next two weeks, in their own words, to allow voters to compare the candidates’ positions directly.The series concludes today with a question focused on must-haves versus nice-to-haves when spending ratepayer dollars.Public consultation often results in a wide range of opinions. When the community is divided, how do you decide which way to vote? Will you always stick to the majority view, or are you prepared to make an unpopular decision if you believe it’s in the district’s best long-term interest?Andrew DowlingI listen to all points of view and then weigh up the pros and cons of each. From this I can then make the best decisions.At a governance level you are often privy to information that is not for the general public, this is a privilege and a responsibility. The responsibility is to use that information wisely to make the best decision for the region.I feel that division comes more from people not feeling listened to or having only one side of the story, rather than extreme views. We are a democracy. This gives you the right to have a view point and also the safety to be able to express it. We need people to tell us what they think, preferably before a decision is made rather than after!I’ll be making decisions that best suit our district and be prepared to explain my position.(I hope those who make all the noise also take the responsibility to vote!)Nat JamiesonPublic consultation is essential, not because it produces a single 'right' answer, but because it helps decision-makers understand the impacts, concerns, and trade-offs different people are facing. When opinions are divided, I would look carefully at who is affected, how strongly views are held, and what the long-term consequences of each option might be.I don’t believe a councillor’s role is simply to count hands and follow the majority every time. My responsibility would be to weigh community feedback alongside evidence, cost, risk, and long-term outcomes for the whole district. If the majority view aligns with what is sustainable and fair in the long run, I would support it. But if I genuinely believed an alternative decision better protected the district’s future, I would be prepared to make that call - even if it was unpopular - provided I could clearly explain my reasoning and remain accountable to the community.Louise van der VoortCommunity consultation is an important part of good decision making, but it is not the only thing councillors must consider. Consultation helps decision-makers understand community sentiment, surface local knowledge, and identify issues or perspectives that may not otherwise be obvious. It also provides an opportunity for questions, challenge, and debate, all of which strengthen decisions.However, many council decisions are complex and highly technical, involving legislation, long-term financial implications, risk management, and specialist advice. In these cases, decisions cannot be based solely on the volume of submissions received, particularly where participation levels are low or where the issues require a detailed understanding of regulatory or infrastructure systems.My approach would be to enter every decision with an open mind, not predetermined, and to carefully weigh all available information: technical advice, legal and financial considerations, and community feedback. Consultation is not a referendum, but one part of a broader responsibility to act in the district’s best long-term interests.There will be times when leadership requires supporting the majority view, and times when it means making a difficult or unpopular decision. I am prepared to do both, provided decisions are well-informed, transparent, and clearly explained to the community.Important dates for the Vincent by-election: Voting opens: Voting papers will be sent to eligible voters from Friday January 30Voting closes: Midday on Tuesday March 3Read more: Why should the community trust you to represent them, and what does 'transparency' look like to you in practice? - here How will you ensure this ward’s voice is heard while still making responsible decisions for the region as a whole? - here What do you consider a 'must-have' that you would protect at all costs, and what is one 'nice-to-have' service or asset you would be willing to cut or defer to keep rates affordable? - hereHave a story to share or comment to make? Contact editor@centralapp.nz